Week 14 · Primary Source Workshop

Week 14 Primary Source Workshop: Checking a Museum Label on the Emancipation Proclamation

U.S. History to 1877 Free sample edition

Part 1 — The Big Picture

Museum labels, websites, and chatbot summaries all retell the Emancipation Proclamation, and many of them blur what it did, when it is dated, and whose words are inside it. This week you learned that enslaved people fled to Union lines from 1861 on, that the Proclamation of 1863 declared free the enslaved people in the areas then in rebellion, that its opening recites an earlier proclamation of 1862, and that the 13th Amendment of 1865 abolished slavery throughout the United States. In this workshop you act as a researcher checking a draft museum label before it goes on a wall: you source the Proclamation, test eight statements against the record, close-read its two pinned phrases, corroborate it with the 13th Amendment, catch a chatbot making the same kinds of slips, and present your reading in one plain sentence. Slavery and the war are documented facts; the workshop reads the Proclamation as evidence of an order and its reach, never as a debate about whether slavery was wrong.

Time budget: Plan for about 90 minutes.

Part 2 — The Task

Guiding question: What does Abraham Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation of 1863, kept by the National Archives, show about what the order declared and for whom, what does it leave out, and which statements in an illustrative draft museum label survive a check against the record?

Workshop data: Eight statements from an illustrative draft museum label about the Emancipation Proclamation

Source: Eight statements from an illustrative draft museum label written for this workshop and printed in full in Part 4; they come from no real museum, and you check each one against the Emancipation Proclamation as the National Archives presents it and against Chapter 14.

Rows: 8 statements, one row each in the audit table
Columns: statement, verdict, which record you used, and a corrected sentence
Records to check against: the National Archives transcript of the Emancipation Proclamation, the National Archives page for the 13th Amendment, and Chapter 14

Part 3 — Materials & Procedure

Tools and materials

DocsTeach (National Archives, free) or the Library of Congress digital collections (free)
The National Archives transcript of the Emancipation Proclamation
The National Archives page for the 13th Amendment
A notebook or any free note-taking app
One approved chatbot
Any free audio or video recorder, or a phone's voice memo app

Ways of working

source-a-primary-document
contextualize-and-corroborate
close-read-for-what-the-text-says-and-omits
present-and-defend-the-analysis

Procedure

Open the National Archives transcript of the Emancipation Proclamation, which is the one-stop reference on this week's Readings & Resources page. Read the opening paragraphs and note where the recited earlier proclamation begins and where the 1863 order's own words begin. Keep Chapter 14, Section 3, open beside it. Tool: The National Archives transcript of the Emancipation Proclamation. Check: You can point to the recited earlier proclamation and to the start of the 1863 order, and you can name the year the document's own text gives.
Fill in the sourcing table for the Proclamation: who made it, when, why and for whom, what type of document it is, and which host keeps the text. Tool: A notebook or any free note-taking app. Check: All five sourcing rows have an answer, and the type row says presidential proclamation, not constitutional amendment.
For each of the eight label statements, check the National Archives pages and Chapter 14, then write Supported, Contradicted, or Goes beyond the source in the second column and name the record in the third. Write a corrected sentence for every statement that is not Supported. Tool: A notebook or any free note-taking app. Check: Every row has a verdict and a named record, and every row that is not Supported has a corrected sentence.
Count your second column by hand and copy the three counts into the tally table, checking that they add up to the number of statements. Check: The three counts add up to 8, one for each statement.
On the National Archives transcript, use your browser's find command (Ctrl+F, or Cmd+F on a Mac) to search for thenceforward, then for henceforward. Read each passage with the sentences around it, and copy each pinned phrase into your close-reading table letter for letter. Tool: The National Archives transcript of the Emancipation Proclamation. Check: The first search lands on one passage, the second lands on two because the shorter word sits inside the longer one, and your copied phrases match the course's pinned wording, punctuation included.
Search the Library of Congress digital collections or DocsTeach for the words Emancipation Proclamation, and note in your close-reading table whether the search finds a record connected to it and what kind of document it is. Tool: DocsTeach (National Archives, free) or the Library of Congress digital collections (free). Check: Your table names the search words you used and either describes the record you found or says that no record turned up.
Open the National Archives page for the 13th Amendment, also named in Chapter 14, Section 4, and find what the amendment did and the year it was ratified. Note in your close-reading table how it confirms or complicates what the Proclamation declared. Tool: The National Archives page for the 13th Amendment. Check: Your corroboration row names the amendment, its year of ratification, and one way it reaches further than the Proclamation.
Complete the close-reading table: say what each pinned phrase says and where it sits, what the Proclamation leaves out, what was happening around it, and how the amendment confirms or complicates it, then write one plain sentence. Tool: A notebook or any free note-taking app. Check: The table ends in one plain sentence that names what the Proclamation shows and what it does not.
Run the AI-critique step in Part 6 with one approved chatbot, or take the equivalent route printed there, and write your critique report. Tool: One approved chatbot. Check: Your report quotes at least two errors and corrects each with evidence from the National Archives pages, your tables, or Chapter 14.
Present and defend your reading: record a two-minute spoken explanation, or write its script, that sources the Proclamation, gives your close reading, names your corroborating source, and ends in your one plain sentence. Tool: Any free audio or video recorder, or a phone's voice memo app. Check: The explanation runs about two minutes, or about 250 words as a script, and ends in one plain sentence.

Fallback route

When to use it: Use this route if either National Archives page will not load in your browser.

Check the label statements against the record facts printed in the table below, which restate the National Archives pages and Chapter 14 in the course's own words, and tally your second column by hand, showing that the counts add up to 8. Then complete every scaffold table, analysis question, the critique step, and the spoken explanation, and submit the same items for equal credit.

This route earns the same credit as the primary route.

These record facts restate the National Archives pages and Chapter 14, so you can check the statements without loading the pages.

Fallback model data
Record fact	Where it comes from
The Emancipation Proclamation is a presidential proclamation by Abraham Lincoln; its own text dates it the first day of January 1863, and the National Archives keeps it.	National Archives transcript; Chapter 14, Section 3
The 13th Amendment, ratified in 1865, abolished slavery and involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime, throughout the United States.	National Archives page for the 13th Amendment; Chapter 14, Section 4
The Proclamation declared free the enslaved people in the areas then in rebellion; it did not apply to the loyal border states.	Chapter 14, Section 4
The 1863 order's pinned phrase reads: are, and henceforward shall be free.	National Archives transcript
The recited phrase reads: thenceforward, and forever free. It belongs to the preliminary proclamation of 1862, which the 1863 text recites at its opening.	National Archives transcript; Chapter 14, Section 3
The words government of the people, by the people, for the people shall not perish from the earth come from the Gettysburg Address of 1863, a speech, not from the Proclamation.	Chapter 14, Section 6
Enslaved people fled to Union lines from 1861 on, before the Proclamation, and freedom became real as Union armies advanced and as enslaved people reached them.	Chapter 14, Sections 2 and 4
The Proclamation shows that Lincoln, as commander in chief in 1863, declared free the enslaved people in the areas then in rebellion and opened the armed service to Black men; it does not by itself show that every enslaved person went free, or how enslaved people won freedom for themselves.	Chapter 14, Section 4

Part 4 — The Scaffold

The data come first: eight statements from an illustrative draft museum label about the Emancipation Proclamation, with columns for your verdict, the record you checked, and a corrected sentence.

Student scaffold table 1
Statement	Supported, Contradicted, or Goes beyond the source	Which record	Corrected sentence
S1. The Emancipation Proclamation is a presidential proclamation by Abraham Lincoln, dated in its own text 1863, and the National Archives keeps it.
S2. The Emancipation Proclamation was issued in 1865, the year the war ended.
S3. The Emancipation Proclamation is a constitutional amendment that abolished slavery throughout the United States.
S4. The 1863 order declares that the enslaved people in the areas it names "are, and henceforward shall be free".
S5. In its own new words, the 1863 order promises that those people will be "thenceforward, and forever free".
S6. The opening of the 1863 document recites an earlier proclamation, issued in 1862.
S7. Because Lincoln signed the Proclamation, every enslaved person in the country was free by the end of 1863.
S8. The words "government of the people, by the people, for the people shall not perish from the earth" appear in the Emancipation Proclamation.

Tally your second column so you can read the audit as a small dataset.

Student scaffold table 2
Verdict	Count
Supported
Contradicted
Goes beyond the source
Total

Source the Proclamation itself, one sourcing question per row, before you read it closely.

Student scaffold table 3
Sourcing question	Your answer for the Emancipation Proclamation
Who made it
When it is dated, and how that year relates to the 13th Amendment
Why, and for whom
What type of document it is, and how it differs from a constitutional amendment
Which host keeps the text you read

Close-read the two pinned phrases and set the Proclamation beside the 13th Amendment to corroborate or complicate it.

Student scaffold table 4
Move	Your reading
What the 1863 order's pinned phrase says, and where it sits
What the recited 1862 phrase says, and where it sits
What the Proclamation leaves out, and why that matters
Context: what was happening around the Proclamation in 1863
Corroboration: what the 13th Amendment adds
Library or DocsTeach search: words used and what turned up
One plain sentence

Part 5 — Analysis Questions

Using your tally table, how many statements are Supported, how many are Contradicted, and how many Go beyond the source? Show that your three counts add up to the number of statements.
Which statement gives the Emancipation Proclamation words from another of this week's documents, and which document and year do those words come from?
Two statements get the Proclamation's sourcing wrong. Explain what kind of document the Emancipation Proclamation is, how it differs from a constitutional amendment, and what year its own text gives.
Using your close-reading table, how does the 13th Amendment confirm or complicate what the Proclamation declared? Say what the amendment adds that the Proclamation alone does not do.
Choose one and answer it in 3–4 sentences. (a) Name two things the Proclamation cannot tell a historian about how enslaved people became free, and say what kind of evidence each would need. (b) Explain why a document that declares people free is evidence of an order rather than of the freedom people lived, and how a careful reader still uses it.

Part 6 — AI-Critique Moment

Choose one equal-credit critique route. Route A: ask an approved AI tool to critique your completed work, then check its response against your own evidence. Route B is the no-AI equivalent printed below.

Approved tools: Claude, Gemini, ChatGPT, Grok, Microsoft Copilot.

Prompt to paste:

I've pasted my completed Week 14 Primary Source Workshop tables above. They check an illustrative draft museum label about the Emancipation Proclamation. Please do six things. First, summarize the Proclamation in three sentences and say who issued it, what kind of document it is, which archive keeps it, and what year its own text gives. Second, quote word for word the phrase in which the 1863 order declares the people it names free. Third, say whether the Proclamation freed every enslaved person in the United States. Fourth, say what the 13th Amendment did and when it was ratified. Fifth, say which of Lincoln's documents of 1863 contains the words government of the people, by the people, for the people. Sixth, in one short paragraph, connect the Proclamation to earlier American history and preview how it leads to later U.S. history through 1877.

Test the response for these likely failures:

Chatbots often call a modern museum label or encyclopedia summary of the Proclamation a primary source, or treat the archive's exhibit text as Lincoln's own words.
A chatbot reaching back for long background may say the Native nations of North America were conquered the moment Europeans first met them.
A chatbot tracing slavery's long history may call Jamestown the oldest European settlement in what became the United States.
A chatbot describing the plantation economy may say tobacco or maize came to the Americas from Europe.
Chatbots often say that because Lincoln signed the Proclamation in 1863, every enslaved person went free that year, reading the order on paper as proof of what happened on the ground.
A chatbot describing the people the Proclamation named may call them servants bound for a term of years who would have gone free in time.
A chatbot connecting the Gettysburg Address to the founding may say it quotes the Constitution of 1776.
A chatbot explaining how slavery was finally abolished may say the 13th Amendment changed the Articles of Confederation.
A chatbot sketching earlier politics may call the Federalists who campaigned for the Constitution in 1787 and 1788 the same group as the Federalist Party of the 1790s.
A chatbot reaching for founders' words about the Union may credit Washington's Farewell Address with the phrase entangling alliances with none.
Chatbots often date the Proclamation to the year of the preliminary proclamation, 1862, or to the year the war ended, instead of reading the date from the document's own text.
A chatbot giving the war's background may say the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 extended the Missouri Compromise line.
A chatbot setting up the war may say the Civil War was fought over the same tax quarrel that caused the Revolution.
Chatbots often say the Emancipation Proclamation of 1863 abolished slavery everywhere in the United States.
A chatbot running ahead may say the 13th Amendment also made the people it freed citizens and gave Black men the vote.
A chatbot previewing what came after the war may describe Reconstruction as one policy from start to finish.

Write 3–5 sentences naming one thing the chatbot got right and at least two places it went wrong or ran ahead, quoting its words and correcting each with evidence from the National Archives pages, your tables, or Chapter 14; flag any slip about later history as something the course takes up later.

Equivalent route (no AI required)

No AI account is required for this workshop. Instead of the chatbot, critique this flawed analysis, printed here in full: "A modern museum label about the Emancipation Proclamation is Lincoln's own primary account. The Proclamation is dated 1862, the year of the earlier proclamation it recites, and it is a constitutional amendment that abolished slavery throughout the United States. Because Lincoln signed it, every enslaved person was free by the end of 1863. Its own new words promise that the people it names will be thenceforward and forever free, and it ends with the words government of the people, by the people, for the people. The people it named were servants bound for a term of years who would have gone free in time. The Gettysburg Address quotes the Constitution of 1776, and the 13th Amendment changed the Articles of Confederation. The Federalists who backed the Constitution in 1788 were the Federalist Party of the 1790s, and Washington's Farewell Address warned against entangling alliances with none. In 1854 the Kansas-Nebraska Act extended the Missouri Compromise line, and the war was fought over the same tax quarrel that caused the Revolution. Slavery began at Jamestown, the first European settlement in what became the United States; the Native nations were conquered the day Europeans met them; and Europeans brought tobacco and maize to the Americas. Later, the 13th Amendment made the people it freed citizens and voters, and Reconstruction was one policy." Mark it up: quote each flawed sentence, name what is wrong (a later summary read as the author's own primary account, the document dated from the year of a document it recites, a proclamation confused with an amendment, an order on paper read as proof of what happened to everyone, the 1862 phrase given to the 1863 order or reworded, words from the Gettysburg Address given to the Proclamation, slavery and servitude blurred, the Declaration confused with the Constitution, the Articles confused with the Constitution, the ratification-era Federalists confused with a later party, Jefferson's phrase given to Washington, the Missouri Compromise line confused with popular sovereignty, the causes of the Revolution confused with the causes of the Civil War, Jamestown placed before St. Augustine, contact called conquest, the exchange run in the wrong direction, or a later-week confusion to flag because a later week takes it up), cite the evidence from the National Archives pages, your tables, or Chapter 14, and write a corrected sentence beneath it. This route assesses the same objective (Objective 8 — analyze the causes, conduct, and consequences of the Civil War and Reconstruction — emancipation, the Reconstruction amendments, the struggle over Black freedom and citizenship, and why Reconstruction ended in 1877) as the chatbot critique, takes comparable effort (about 30 minutes and 250–350 words), is scored by the same scoring criteria for the same credit, and its own submission artifact is the marked-up flawed analysis, submitted in place of the chatbot share link and report.

Part 7 — What to Submit

All four completed scaffold tables
Written answers to all five analysis questions
The chatbot critique report with its share link, or the equivalent route's marked-up flawed analysis
The two-minute spoken or recorded explanation, or its written script

Deliverable:

A short Primary Source Workshop report on the Emancipation Proclamation: four completed tables (the label audit, the tally, the sourcing table, and the close-reading table), written answers to five analysis questions, a critique of a chatbot's answer about the Proclamation, or, on the equivalent route, a marked-up correction of the printed flawed analysis, and a two-minute spoken explanation or its written script. Submit in any accessible file type or as a link; a recorded response may be submitted as audio or video with a transcript, or as text. Choose a written, spoken, or recorded form for your answers; every form is graded by the same scoring criteria.

Rubric

The rubric below shows how each submitted part is evaluated; bands are full, partial, or none.

Workshop evaluation criteria
Criterion	Full	Partial	None
Sourcing the Proclamation	All five sourcing rows are answered from the record: Abraham Lincoln as the maker, acting as commander in chief, the year 1863 from the document's own text with the 13th Amendment placed later in 1865, a purpose and audience the text supports, presidential proclamation as its type with the difference from a constitutional amendment named, and the National Archives as host.	Most rows are answered, but the Proclamation is called an amendment, its year is wrong, or the host is not named.	The sourcing table is missing, or its answers are copied from a chatbot without checking the record.
Auditing the label against the record	All eight statements carry a verdict and a named record, every statement that is not Supported has a corrected sentence, and the tally counts add up to 8.	The audit is attempted, but one or two verdicts are wrong, a corrected sentence or record is missing, or a count is off.	No audit is recorded, or the verdicts come from a chatbot with no record named.
Close reading, context, and corroboration	Both pinned phrases are read for what they say and placed with the right proclamation, the Proclamation is read for what it leaves out, set in the war year of 1863, and corroborated or complicated with the 13th Amendment or another named source, ending in one plain sentence.	The close reading is attempted, but the corroborating source is unnamed, a phrase is placed with the wrong proclamation, or the reading stops at what the phrases say.	No close reading or corroboration appears.
Critique of the chatbot or of the printed flawed analysis	On either route, at least two errors are quoted and corrected with evidence from the National Archives pages, the tables, or Chapter 14, later-week slips are flagged as coming later, and one correct point is acknowledged; both routes earn this band equally.	On either route, errors are named but corrected without evidence, or only one error is caught.	No critique appears, or pasted output is submitted without any checking.
Presenting and defending the reading	The spoken explanation or its script sources the Proclamation, gives the close reading, names the corroborating source, and ends in one plain sentence that says what the Proclamation shows and what it does not.	The explanation is given, but one of those moves is missing or the plain sentence overclaims what the Proclamation shows.	No explanation or script is submitted.
Reflection on the limits of the source	The chosen reflection option is answered in 3–4 sentences that name a specific limit of a proclamation as evidence and the evidence or reasoning it calls for.	The reflection is answered but stays general.	No reflection is submitted.

Quality Gate

Every verdict in the audit table names the record it came from, a National Archives page or Chapter 14, never a chatbot.
The three tally counts add up to 8, one for each statement.
The Proclamation is sourced as Abraham Lincoln's presidential proclamation of 1863, kept by the National Archives, and kept apart from the 13th Amendment of 1865.
Every quotation matches a pinned phrase word for word, punctuation included; no quotation, date, figure, person, or document is invented anywhere in the submission.
The submission states slavery and the war plainly, says enslaved people in its own voice, names the people who fled to Union lines as part of the story, and compares no part of the 1860s with any present-day party, monument, or policy.
The critique quotes the chatbot or the flawed analysis and corrects at least two errors with evidence from the record or the chapter.
The spoken explanation or its script ends in one plain sentence that names what the Proclamation shows and what it does not.

Built with The Course Maker · samples.thecoursemaker.com